top of page
Search

(England) Parents worried about legal rights under special ed reforms

1 hour ago
3 min read

Families of children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) in England could gain new ways to challenge school decisions under changes being considered as part of the government's major education reform.


The proposals come after parents, charities and campaigners raised concerns that the planned system could weaken families' legal rights to secure the support their children need.

Two possible independent appeal routes are reportedly being considered. One would allow parents to take complaints to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, while another could create independent review panels to examine disputes between families and schools.


The discussions follow criticism of the government's February white paper, which proposes reducing the number of children receiving Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs) and replacing much of the existing system with new support arrangements managed by schools.


Under the proposed changes, more children would receive Individual Support Plans (ISPs), which would explain their needs, the help they should receive and the goals schools hope to achieve. However, unlike EHCPs, the new arrangements could leave parents with fewer opportunities to challenge decisions through an independent tribunal.


The possibility of limiting access to the SEND tribunal has become one of the biggest concerns surrounding the reforms. Parents and advocacy groups argue that allowing schools to handle complaints about their own support decisions would not provide enough protection for children who are denied necessary educational services or specialist therapies.


Education Secretary Lucy Powell has indicated that the government is considering changes to the appeals process. Speaking to Parliament's Education Select Committee, she told MPs to "wait and see" and described the issue as an important part of the ongoing policy discussions.


The government has not confirmed which appeal system it will adopt. Its response to the consultation and the legislation needed to introduce the reforms are not expected until early next year.


Independent SEND Appeals Considered


The two possible appeal routes would give families an independent body to review disagreements about the support provided to children with special educational needs.

The first option would extend the role of the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman. The organization already investigates complaints involving local authorities, including disputes over SEND services and school transportation.


Under the proposal, parents could potentially use the ombudsman's services to challenge problems with the support their children receive directly from schools.


This approach has received support from Independent Provider of Special Education Advice (Ipsea), a charity that helps families understand their legal rights and navigate the SEND system.

Madeleine Cassidy, Ipsea's chief executive, said it was "encouraging" that ministers were considering alternatives after concerns about reducing the powers of the existing tribunal.

She explained that the organization had long supported extending the ombudsman's authority to schools so that complaints about SEND provision could receive an independent review.


However, Cassidy warned that creating additional complaint procedures should not replace the legal protections families currently have.


"The proposal to weaken the powers of the SEND tribunal and reduce families' opportunities to challenge decisions has been a significant source of concern for parents and carers of children and young people with SEND." . . .


The second option under discussion would establish independent review panels similar to those used when parents challenge school exclusion decisions.


These panels are appointed by local authorities and include a clerk and up to five experts who have no direct connection to the school involved. They can review exclusion decisions and have the authority to overturn them.


A similar arrangement for SEND disputes could give parents access to people with relevant experience who can examine whether schools have made appropriate decisions about a child's education and support. . . .


"So any new appeals system must give parents a genuinely independent, swift and effective way to challenge decisions and secure the education and therapy their children need to thrive.


"Schools and nurseries cannot be expected to mark their own homework, however. Leaving them with the final say would not only undermine parents' confidence in the system but also risk damaging relationships between families and the very people responsible for supporting their children every day.


"Whatever body hears appeals, the people hearing them must be independent and have the right expertise, and their decisions must be legally meaningful and lead to timely action. Anything else leaves children at risk."


Her comments reflect a central concern among campaigners: parents should not have to depend entirely on the same school they are challenging to decide whether their complaint is justified.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page